Slightly jealous
I spent probably far too many visits to the general area of the Pike Place Market over the past week in Seattle. But it’s a really impressive space.
One of the things that struck me is its longevity and how it survived numerous challenges where sections of it may have been torn down or redeveloped.
It made me somewhat jealous of what Seattle has and what we’re not accomplishing in Pittsburgh’s strip district, which while it has many awesome attribute, it could be great. Sure the Terminal Building was largely saved (I really can’t imagine what it would be like 1/3rd shorter), it’s becoming a bland corporate destination rather than a more organic, quasi public space. We really need to do better here.
Water Dog
I’ve long wanted a dog that can ride on top of a kayak and on a recent vacation I was able to train Jax to sit on top of my boat. No spills despite him being a chaos pup!
Christmas Eve
It’s 60F (15C) today here in Pittsburgh. While it’s nice to spend some time outside, it makes it hard to not be concerned about climate change. Pittsburgh’s December temperature typically ranges from 30-40F, so this seems to be not normal. Playing outside with the kids seems like a great example of shifting baseline syndrome.
Been busy
In part due to this guy… be back soon…
Effects of Bridges on River Scour
The bridge that carries Route 381 over the Youghiogheny River has been there a fairly long time. At least in some form or another. We have often wondered if the placement of the piers have affected the river scour at this site, as there is a downward trend in the habitat quality at this particular site. The pier is directly in front of the scour and may deflect the following water from directly hitting the scour.
A bridge pier in front of the a river scour. The Youghiogheny is flowing from the right to the left.
The other side of the bridge pier from the previous photo.
Just downstream of here, one can see a lot of the grasses are bent in the upstream direction, indicating that there’s some sort of eddy operating here. I’ve seen similar eddys at the downstream end of river scours before, typically after a series of rapids.
So many interesting questions about scour hydrology!
Book Review: The Future of Conservation in America
My friend Lisa Smith, executive director of the Natural Areas Association convinced me to buy this book, The Future of Conservation in America: A Chart for Rough Water, at the NAA table at the Pennsylvania Botany Symposium. The authors, Jonathan Jarvis and Gary Machlis, delivered the closing plenary based on this book at the 2018 NAA Conference (I had to unfortunately miss it due to the Northeast Natural Heritage meeting scheduled at the same time). Unfortunately, this sat on the back of my couch for far too long before getting a chance to read it over the holiday break.
In short, this is a great short book. The authors, with decades of experience in the conservation field, are well qualified to cover this topic. They skillfully weave the core contributions of land protection and conservation science with the social, economic, and political facets of conservation. Speaking of politics, this book doesn’t shy away from the politics that affect land and water protection. As I write this, the federal government is in day seven of a shutdown over funding for Trump’s ecologically destructive (and frankly ridiculous) border wall. The authors don’t fail to recall that the previous long government shutdown was ended in part of by access to our national parks:
… the sixteen-day federal government shutdown in 2013 became an exercise in political theater, diversion of administrative effort, and economic disruption. The public outcry over the closure of parks ultimately forced the hand of Congress but reaffirmed the strong position that public lands have in American society.
(page 27)
They make the case that conservation in the future may be impeded by the lack of public support for science, especially as it relates to climate change.
Additionally, I was pleased to see a small shout-out to NatureServe and its Network of Natural Heritage Programs:
“Nonprofit organizations like The Nature Conservancy or NatureServe maintain their own research staffs…”
(page 74)
Natural Heritage data has a role in almost every natural area conservation decision in the US, and its unfortunately frequently unappreciated as part of the process. It’s good to see it referenced here.
This book is a great short read and has an inspiring message to an issue that seems dark at times. Highly recommended.
This book is available directly through the publisher or probably can be ordered through your favorite bookseller.
ps. A video of Machlis and Jarvis’ talk at the NAA meeting can be found here. Check it out after you read the book, or before, or even if you don’t read this book.
#365 Papers
As I've gotten more active on science Twitter after a long absence, I recently become more aware of the #365papers thing. Digging into it, it seems like something I would be into: reading papers, sharing them, setting unrealistic goals...
I'm going to set some rules:
- As some others have said, reading a paper a day and having a non-work life might be an un-attainable goal, so let's start with just reading one a work day, so that should be 260 days per year.
- As I'm starting late in the year, let's make the 2018 goal somewhere around 80 papers.
- Only counting papers that I read through the results and discussion sections.
- Book chapters, reports, etc that follow the a general paper format count.
I'll update a list of the papers read here below.
3D maps
Recently, I’ve been beginning to dabble in 3D GIS, something I have very little experience with. Co-incidentally, on a recent trip through Ontario, I came across this incredible example of a 3D mine map. Each map “sheet” was printed on plexiglass, and stored in a custom cabinet, lit from below, so they are below so the structure and relationships between the levels of the mine could be examined. A pretty great example of 3D mapping before it was commonplace.
A 3D map of a mine (at the Bancroft Mineral Museum)
Perceptions of Probability
from https://github.com/zonination/perceptions
I'm currently working on a project where we are presenting information on the possible presence of particular species at sites across the state. We're considering the fairly ordinary words of 'high', 'medium', and 'low' to describe the probability, These words, of course, can connote a particular meaning to the users of this analysis. In order to make a decision on which words to use, we're beginning to look at the mean behind commonly used phrases.
This great work, by redditor zonation, provides of some great examples of what a surveys mean. This is based on Sherman Kent's work in the 1960's. Its definately provides a great framework to understand how people may understand our data presentation.
River Scour in Winter
An icy Youghiogheny River at Ohiopyle, Pennsylvania (January 2018).
One of my favorite plant communities are Floodplain Scours -- areas of relative bare rock that occur along the banks of major rivers where rock outcrops are subject to winter ice scour and high-velocity flooding. Along the Youghiogheny River in Fayette County, PA these communities occur along bedrock shelves and boulders. The ice and flooding removes competition from many plant species allowing a number of threatened and endangered species such as rock grape (Vitis rupestris), Carolina tassel-rue (Trautvetteria caroliniensis) and large-flowered Barbara's buttons (Marshallia grandiflora) to survive.
Last weekend, my colleague Pete Woods and I went down to the Yough to check out these scour zones during ice conditions as we figured it would be a good time to check out the ice conditions as this region of the country had been in a multiweek deep freeze. In fact, the thermometer on the car read as low as -15F on the way down (it did warm up to nearly 20F by the time we left shortly after lunch.
A large chunk of ice resting on the scour zone.
Remains of last year's Large Flowered Barbara’s-buttons (Marshallia grandiflora) along the Youghiogheny's scour zone.
Floodplain Scour communities are most likely declining due to destruction of plant populations and the alteration of ecosystem processes needed to maintain these populations. Alteration of the natural flooding regimes through construction of dams and other impoundments has greatly impacted the plant composition. As the amount and frequency of flooding and ice-scour are the most critical factors maintaining the quality and persistence of this community, factors that can change these attributes such as the effects of global climate change is the potential loss of ice scour as the climate warms.
Even in the middle of winter, we found some lichens to collect. This particular rock is fairly inaccessible during the growing season, so it was interesting to look at up close.
Porg Ecology
We're a little over a week away from the opening of Star Wars: The Last Jedi, the latest installment in the Star Wars franchise. While I've been diligently avoiding any major spoilers for the film, its been hard to miss the mania around Porgs--one of the new creatures that will make their debut in this movie.
As a portion of the movie was shot on the Irish island of Skellig Michael, providing the location of the planet -- where Luke Skywalker spent many years in exile before he was found at the end of Star Wars: The Force Awakens, one of the challenges the filmmakers had to deal with was the abundant seabird colonies. Species using the island for breeding habitat include the Atlantic Puffins (Fratercula arctica), Fulmars (Fulmarus glacialis), Arctic Terns (Sterna paradisaea), and Northern Gannets (Morus bassanus). Apparently, birds were frequently seen in the background of shots. Rather than trying to digitally remove them, they decided to go all in and use them as (minor???) characters in the film, now known as Porgs.
Based on the relatively scarce information released on them, Porgs appear to be based on the puffin, however, at least to my eyes, they cross taxonomic classes and have the face of an otter. Rian Johnson, the movie's director put out some additional details in a tweet a while back:
They are sea birds. Their coloring varies. Males are slightly larger than females. They can fly short distances. They're inquisitive.
— Rian Johnson (@rianjohnson) September 13, 2017
The young are also apparently called porglets. I'm a little skeptical that they can fly well based on the size of their wings, but aerodynamics are one thing that don't always make sense in Star Wars. This short animation Disney put out over the summer shows that they are also a gregarious species and they appear to be as clumsy on the ground as their inspiration, the puffin. From this clip, as well as a brief appearance in a trailer, it seems Porgs can vocalize, while their real-life counterparts are silent except for a chainsaw-like growl when they are in their burrows.
One of the interesting things about this are the ecological impacts of filming at this location, as it is an important breeding site for puffins and the other seabirds that call the site home as well as a UNESCO World Heritage site. Apparently there was some controversy from the filming during the relatively short amount of time the island was in the The Force Awakens, as some of the bird species were still breeding at the site and disturbed by the activity. Additional precautions and measures were put in place for the sequel, but the long term effects of the use of the site are unknown at this time. An additional complicating influence will be increased tourism to the site, something the Irish government hopes island’s film appearance will help bring.
The Tiniest Azalea
Alpine-azalea (Kalmia procumbens) in fruit.
One of the highlights of the botanical finds I had during this past trip to Newfoundland was the Alpine-azalea (Kalmia procumbens). This small shrub is a member of the Ericaceae that forms a cushion-like mound about 10 centimeters (4 inches) tall. Inhabiting northern, alpine regions around the world, it has tiny pink flowers tucked in between the leathery, opposite leaves. Like many of the plants I had wanted to see, I had missed this species in flower, but the fruits were just as cool.
The compact growth form is known in botanical circles as a "cushion plant" growth form is found in alpine habitats across the world and across a number of plant families. These are actually masses of individual stems that grow very slowly and at the same rate so one stem is not more exposed than then another. This allows the plants to survive cold and harsh climates. Additionally, its tough leaf cuticles protect it from the cold winds that can dessicate the plants.
More details about this species can be found on Go Botany.
Habitat for alpine azalea at Mistaken Point Ecological Reserve.
Fringed Gentian
Today, I stopped by the aptly named Fringed Gentian Fen a small piece of protected wetland just north of Pittsburgh. One of the highlights of this site is a good sized population of Fringed Gentian (Gentianopsis crinita).
Gentianopsis crinita
This species is only found in a few scattered locations in western Pennsylvania, whereas it's a little more abundant in the eastern part of the state. It's usually found in richer, open wetlands, although I've also seen it along stream banks in Erie County. It's truly one of the most striking wildflowers in the region.
This species is the inspiration behind one of William Cullen Gentian's poems.
To the Fringed Gentian
Thou blossom bright with autumn dew,
And colored with the heaven’s own blue,
That openest when the quiet light
Succeeds the keen and frosty night.
Thou comest not when violets lean
O’er wandering brooks and springs unseen,
Or columbines, in purple dressed,
Nod o’er the ground-bird’s hidden nest.
Thou waitest late and com’st alone,
When woods are bare and birds are flown,
And frosts and shortening days portend
The aged year is near his end.
Then doth thy sweet and quiet eye
Look through its fringes to the sky,
Blue-blue-as if that sky let fall
A flower from its cerulean wall.
I would that thus, when I shall see
The hour of death draw near to me,
Hope, blossoming within my heart,
May look to heaven as I depart.
Threats to Public Land in a Galaxy Far, Far Away.
Outside of ecology and conservation, one of the things that I am really into is Star Wars. A few months ago, Rogue One, the first anthology film in the Star Wars universe was released. This was preceded by a tie-in novel, Catalyst, that is a prequel to the the movie. The events in the book take place from the somewhere before the events portrayed in Star Wars: Episode III – Revenge of the Sith to immediately prior to the events of the 2016 Star Wars Anthology film Rogue One.
Note: spoilers for both the book and the movie follow, so proceed at your own risk.
As even the most casual fan of Star Wars knows, the Death Star is the size of a "small moon". A space station of this size would have to take an amazing amount of raw materials to build. I often wondered about the resources it would take to build such a station, not to mention the all the other ships of the Empire and the Rebel Alliance.
The Catalyst novel covers some of the exploitation of these resources during the two decades before the Battle of Yavin. As the Death Star is the the signature of the Empire, they are in a ruthless in its pursuit of the incredible amount of natural resources. While many planets were open to resource extraction, they also introduced the concept of a "Legacy World"--a term for planets that were environmentally-protected and legally exempted from exploitation. Limited industrial presences on this world were regulated so to be low-impact. The Empire finds ways to override environmental protections on these Legacy Worlds. When the Empire cannot simply claim these protected resources for themselves, they trump up falsehoods as justification for annexing resource-rich planets and taking what they need. In the end many planets are devastated by the Death Star project.
While reading this book, I could help to see the parallels between story and current efforts by some facets of Federal and state governments, corporations, and other parties to reduce or eliminate environmental protections on publicly owned land in the US, largely in the name of economic development. While it was a little stressful to read a book for entertainment that so strongly reminded me of work, it was good to see this issue covered in (semi-)popular media. So much for escapism though...
Atlantic Puffins!
During my last visit to Newfoundland, my friend Emma and I made a ridiculous journey from across Newfoundland and back over the course of about 30 hours, all in the idea of seeing puffins. One of the folks that we met on the Long Range Traverse mentioned this great place on the east coast, where one could view a puffin colony from land. Intrigued, we drove to Elliston, NL to see some Atlantic Puffins (Fratercula arctica) --a first for both of us. It was a short trip, but well worth it.
On this recent return trip that Martha, Ellery, and I recently took, one of our must-see stops was a revisit to Elliston, so Ellery could see her second-favorite seabird. Leaving Gander early on a Sunday morning, we stopped for a few hours on our way towards St. John's. The puffin viewing on this visit was amazing. One of the fascinating things about this site, is that the island that the puffin colony is on is only about 150 meters from mainland. Its probably the closest that one can view these birds where one doesn't have to be on a boat. The morning we visited had puffins hanging out on the mainland, many of them only a few meters from where we were sitting.
A new (old) cactus species for Pennsylvania.
The flower of Opuntia cespitosa. Notice the red-orange bases of the tepals, compared to the pure yellow flowers of O. humifusa.
A few weekends ago, I was messing around on Facebook, when a blog post by the New England Wildflower Society caught my eye. This article highlighted a split in of the eastern prickly pear cactus (Opuntia humifusa) into two species--O. humifusa and O. cespitosa. I shared it with our botanist at work, and he agreed that it appeared to be a valid taxonomic split, supported by a variety of methods. It's interesting that O. cespitosa is an originally a name given by Rafinesque in the 1800s. Like, many of the species Rafinesque described, there was no type species available and, over time, the species was lumped into O. humifusa. The recent work that led to the resurrection of this species was done by Lucas Majure (papers linked from here).
Notice the long spines on the pads, this is one of the features that differentiated this species from Opuntia humifusa.
Looking around in the online herbarium databases (the benefits of digitized collections), we found a putative example of this species in Pennsylvania from an 1862 specimen along the Susquehanna River. Not being aware of any extant populations, we were planning on ending this to the Pennsylvania flora as an extirpated species.
However, I was up in Erie County working on vegetation plots, when we came across a small population of Opuntia that I had documented a few years previously. Back then, I had called it O. humifusa, as I wasn't aware of another taxon in the state at the time. However, this time the species was in flower, and it was obvious from that this was indeed O. cepitosa given the red-orange coloration of the flower and the long spines. This was a fairly exciting change in identity for this population of the species, especially as we now have a confirmed extant population of this species in Pennsylvania.
A Checklist of the Bryophytes of Erie County, Pennsylvania
My colleague Scott Schuette and I recently published an updated checklist of the bryophytes (mosses, liverworts, and hornworts) of Erie County, Pennsylvania. We began this project back in 2012, when Scott was asked to help arrange for the annual Crum Workshop (a regional bryophyte foray) to be hosted somewhere in Pennsylvania. We were just in the process of wrapping up the update to the Erie County Natural Heritage Inventory--so we thought that would a great location to host the workshop. Through this five-day gathering of bryologists and additional inventory through heritage survey work, we increased the known number of bryophyte species in the county from 82 to 199, with eight species reported for the first time in Pennsylvania. More details in the abstract:
One hundred ninety-nine species of bryophytes are documented for Erie County, Pennsylvania, representing 34% of the Pennsylvania bryophyte flora. This work is the result of scattered surveys over multiple years and the 2012 Crum Workshop. Aneura maxima, Calypogeia integristipula, C. sphagnicola, Fuscocephaloziopsis loitlesbergeri, F. macrostachya, F. pleniceps, Cephaloziella hyalina, and Campylium protensum are reported new to the state, and an 83 species are reported new for the county. Nearly 40% of the species on this list are considered “rare” and tracked as critically imperiled (S1), imperiled (S2), or vulnerable (S3) by Pennsylvania Natural Heritage Program, highlighting the critical role of intensive surveys for bryophyte conservation.
For those interested in reading the full article, and have library access, here is the link on BioOne. Also, the Crum Workshop will be hosted in Pennsylvania again this year. It will be held in the State College area and we'll again be visiting several different habitats for bryophyte inventory.